3 Tips to select a Mutual Fund scheme

Magnifying glass placed over a newspaper listing mutual funds, symbolising careful analysis and key tips for selecting the right mutual fund scheme.

Choose mutual funds based on their vintage, fund size, and the track record of the fund manager. Avoid NFOs and seek guidance from a qualified financial advisor for better investment decisions.

The Mutual Fund industry has grown in leaps and bounds in the recent past. It is estimated that nearly Rs. 20 lakh crores (20 trillion) of investments are now parked into Mutual Fund schemes as on date. Along with booming markets come an inevitable plethora of NFO’s (New Fund Offers) which are best avoided. If you’re new to Mutual Funds, and have zeroed in on the type of fund that you’d like to invest into (equity, debt or hybrid), here are four simple criteria which should determine your choice of fund selection.

Vintage & Track Record

Rather than focusing obsessively on ‘star ratings’ assigned by agencies such as CRISIL, Morningstar or Valueresearch, you should instead evaluate the fund’s vintage and track record instead. Go for a fund that has a track record of at least ten years. Even better, check out how the fund has navigated difficult market phases or volatile periods. For instance, if it’s an equity fund, check how the fund performs ed during the meltdown of 2008. Did it deftly adjust its cash position, and did it de-risk itself prior to the crash, or did it simply follow the herd? It’s easy for funds to make hay while the sun shines – it’s true mettle can only be tested during bearish market cycles.

Fund Size

Go for a fund that’s neither too large, nor too small. If a fund is too small, it’s likely that the talent at the top will at best, be mediocre. It is the larger funds that attract the most talented fund managers. Conversely, a fund becoming too large in size may render it unwieldy and difficult to manage, affecting its performance. This is one of the reasons why many small and mid-cap funds actually shut themselves from fresh subscriptions when they cross a certain size threshold! For diversified or large cap equity funds, stick to those that are in the range of 5,000 to 10,000 Crores. For small and mid-cap funds, its best to stick with funds that have assets under management below 5,000 Crores.

Fund Manager Profile and Track Record

Remember – in the end, individual brilliance at Fund Management will make a difference to a fund’s returns. Before zeroing in on a fund, evaluate the track record of the fund manager who would be taking the investment decisions with your hard-earned money. Avoid funds that are managed by greenhorns with low levels of market experience, even if they carry impressive management degrees or qualifications. Skim through the track records of the other funds managed by the same manager, and (if possible) read their interviews to understand their basic fund management philosophies. Also, look out for fund managers who consistently generate ‘alpha’ or outperformance by taking the occasional out of the box investment call or stock pick; not those who blindly follow the herd to negate their own career risks!

End Note: A qualified Financial Advisor can help you with the evaluation, and eventual selection of a top performing mutual fund. If you’re a first-time investor, its best to seek the support of an advisor before venturing into Mutual Funds.

mutual funds

Your Investing Experts

Relevant Articles

Large vs Mid Cap allocation banner with wooden blocks and FinEdge branding background

Why Mid-Cap Allocation Needs More Discipline Than Large Cap

Mid-cap allocation demands more discipline than large cap because it comes with sharper market swings. While mid caps offer higher long-term growth potential, they also test investor patience during downturns. The key is not choosing one over the other, but understanding how each behaves across market cycles.

Return Chasing Fails banner with stock market volatility chart background and FinEdge logo

Why Return-Focused Investing Fails in Volatile Markets

Return-focused investing fails in volatile markets because it relies on recent performance as the primary decision-making anchor. When markets fluctuate sharply, investors who chase returns tend to react emotionally switching funds, exiting prematurely, or increasing risk at the wrong time. Over time, these reactions interrupt compounding and damage long-term wealth creation.

Net Asset Value (NAV) meaning and formula with rising coins growth arrows

What Is NAV in Mutual Fund? A Simple Guide to Understanding Net Asset Value

If you are trying to understand what NAV in mutual fund investing means, the answer is simple: NAV, or net asset value, represents the per-unit value of a mutual fund’s portfolio after deducting its liabilities. It tells you how much each unit you hold is worth at the end of a trading day. It does not indicate whether a fund is cheap, expensive, or better than another, it is simply a daily valuation measure.